For a fashion store focused on growing an email list, I'd start with one of these:
- Klaviyo (onsite forms): My top pick if you use or plan to use Klaviyo for email. Its forms connect directly to your segments and flows, so a new subscriber can get a welcome series and product-based follow-ups without extra setup. It has a free tier, and its targeting (exit intent, time delay, scroll depth, returning visitors) is strong.
- Privy: A popular Shopify-native choice with good templates, spin-to-win and discount popups, and built-in email and SMS. It's easy to set up and works well for promo-driven fashion brands, especially during sales.
- OptinMonster: The most powerful option for advanced targeting and A/B testing. It suits stores with some optimization experience who want fine control over when and where popups appear. It's pricier and has more of a learning curve.
Tips for a fashion store specifically:
- Offer a clear incentive, such as 10–15% off the first order or early access to new drops. Fashion shoppers respond well to exclusivity.
- Use exit-intent popups on product and cart pages rather than showing a popup immediately on arrival, which annoys first-time visitors.
- Segment by interest if possible (women's, men's, sale, new arrivals) so your emails stay relevant.
- Keep mobile in mind. Most fashion traffic is mobile, so make sure the popup is small, easy to close, and doesn't cover the whole screen.
- Test one variable at a time, like offer size or timing, and let each test run long enough to be meaningful.
If you tell me your monthly traffic, your email platform, and your budget, I can narrow this down further.